Lifestyle

2016 Tone Report Weekly Fantasy Pedalboard Draft

Comments

2497

The NFL Draft is now behind us, which means there are still a few weeks left until the season starts and—more importantly—a few weeks left until fantasy football begins.

With fantasy sports being such a significant cultural phenomenon, we here at TRW decided to do something a little different to keep our minds sharp: a fantasy pedalboard challenge.

The rules were simple: eight players, ten rounds and the whole world of guitar pedals to build one gig-worthy board to rule them all.

There were a few caveats though:
• Once a pedal is picked, it is permanently removed from the pool
• Choices must be actual pedals and not just effects units
• Big multi-fx pedals (like the Line 6 M9) are strictly forbidden

Those participating in the draft included eight of TRW’s finest editorial contributors: Phillip Dodge, David A. Evans, Ian Garrett, Sam Hill, Nicholas Kula, Yoel Kreisler, Fletcher Stewart and Eric Tischler.

I, Nick Rambo, acted as moderator and will provide some round-by-round insight and analysis below. 

Here’s how it all went down:

The idea of a “fantasy pedalboard draft” was a novel concept from the start. Unlike fantasy sports, which are governed by complex scoring mechanics, position scarcity and varying tiers of talent-based predictability, the determining factors at play here were considerably more subjective. And yet, seeing a vintage Big Muff go as the number one overall pick made complete sense. In Yoel’s words, “Every board needs a Big Muff, so why not start with the ultimate classic?”

The Rockbox at #2 still seems like a bit of a reach in retrospect, but in what wound up being a drive-heavy first round, perhaps Eric was just ahead of the curve. And he managed to snag his favorite drive pedal right off the bat. “This is still the most throaty-but-stringy, articulate and dynamic OD I've ever played. And if I can't get my OD right, I can't get my mojo working.” 

The steal of the round had to be the Strymon Timeline at #6. I expected it to go in the top three, so I’m sure Nicholas was happy to see it slide down to him at #6. He stated from the beginning that his strategy was geared toward “max computational power,” so starting with the current king of the megadelays is a fantastic first step.

Side Note: it was awesome to see a couple of my favorite pedals go in the first round. The remarkably versatile Lunar Module and hauntingly ambient Dispatch Master have both spent a considerable amount of time on my real-life pedalboard.

 

The run on compressors in such an early round was a surprise. I can’t fault the actual selections much, but with a ton of pedals still in play, so many compressors so early seemed hasty. For Ian and Phillip, compression is a foundational element of their respective tonal arsenals, so checking that off the list ASAP was clearly a priority.

David said the Saffron Squeeze offered “warm compression that doesn’t suck tone or produce that terrible, distorted crunch that some cheap analog compressors do.”

And of the Pale Green, Phillip said, “It’s almost always on and makes life (or at least my tone and playing) a little better.”

The best value pick here though was clearly the Twosome Fuzz. Eric said it was a “no-brainer” at the time and how can you argue with the logic? The Twosome is an absolute monster and comes with nearly unlimited fuzz tones.

Also interesting to note that Fletcher and Yoel grabbed pedals they reviewed for previous issues of Tone Report. For Fletcher it was the GFI System Specular Reverb 2, which he said is “as good or better than any rack or pedal.” And for Yoel, the Source Audio Nemesis Delay, a pedal that has “everything he could ever want from a delay.” High praise on both accounts.

 

Electro-Harmonix has completely dominated the draft to this point. The NYC-based company is essentially the Ohio State of pedal builders. Through 24 picks, EHX has already tallied four selections—and all by different players.

Phillip said the C9 probably seemed like an odd choice, but that he’d fallen in love with the Shimmer and Mellotron settings. ”They sound extremely cool on their own, but they are even better for building a pad under clean and slightly dirty rhythm parts.”

And there was quite a bit of discussion in the draft about Ian’s pick of the Thorpy FX Muffroom Cloud. He called it “his new favorite Muff” and said the interaction of the controls was “brilliant.” It seemed that this was one that a few others were hoping to get in a later round.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

100 Comments

  1. Paul

    This was by far the most entertaining article you all have done. Such a clever idea! It was cool to see all the reviewers that we have come to know pick these new, and old, pedals. Just super fun. Keep up the great work and thanks for a great read! - See more at: http://tonereport.com/blogs/tone-tips/space-explorers-5-new-must-have-reverbs#sthash.QhjfMxuu.dpuf

  2. Nick Rambo

    Thanks for the awesome feedback, Paul. Glad you loved it.

  3. David Outten

    This was hugely entertaining. So interesting to see what people pick , and how their choices match the same strategies of actual NFL GMs. Maybe I’m looking to far into it, but some pick based on value, some pick based upon what they have reviewed personally (like an official visit from a draft prospect). So fun!

    Wish that at the end it showed each “team’s” draft results, so we can put together a pedalboard of their choices.
    I also hope this happens every year to see how it changes due to new products and new pedal needs.

  4. Professor K

    This was a great idea. A lot of fun.

    If Jimi’s wah was on the list, I’m surprised his Fuzz Face wasn’t, too.

  5. Hayden Howell

    Just started guitar I want to make some awesome sounds with

  6. Hayden Howell

    I just started guitar and I want to make some awesome sounds

  7. sslim

    i’d love to have the board you guys left on the table

    ethos overdrive
    chase bliss brothers
    dr scientist bitquest
    red panda particle
    empress echosystem
    strymon big sky
    pigtronix infinity
    sonuus wahoo
    gigrig g2
    and if an eventide h9 is fair, a line6 m9

  8. sslim

    oops, i meant a line 6 m5

  9. Agizorninfize

    Youtube, a video search channel, is number 3.There are a variety of elements that comprise proper Search Engine Optimization. Author Resource:-Faxless payday loans though sound amazing and seem lucrative but in reality, you have to be very vigilant and careful of the lenders who can use you for their fraudulent activities. This is because this way, they can get to assess their performance and tell when they are ready to take the riding assessment.com to get the newest working Norton reviews 2014. Consequently, let’s now shift towards the down sides of loans being taken from faxless payday loans direct lenders:. <a >Wholesale NFL Jerseys Free Shipping</a>.Want to find out more about best SEO practices, then visit Ken Acree’s site to see how SocialAdr can help meet your needs. Perhaps you need to add some further detail concerning the product,<a >Cheap Jerseys China</a>, otherwise you want to market it additional with a particular coupon code. If a swimming pool is no longer being used as often as it used to, the homeowner may decide to just demolish the pool rather than spend on maintenance for something that is no longer being used.They need consistency. Break down large, complex concerns into little goals that you can simply accomplish.<a >Wholesale Jerseys From China</a>. Against the exams that we contain done, it incorporates develop into apparent that Frontline Rogue Remover is the most straightforward resource at eradicating Website Antivirus 2011 against your Computer comprehensively.
    Visit my site??http://www.wholesalenfljerseys-cheap.com/

  10. Golpaxolf

    american cash advance slidell la

        payday loan cash loan

      halifax small loan calculator

  11. Nadezhdaaxolf

    cialis for sale gta

        http://cialisuyb.com/ - order cialis online

      generic cialis online

      cialis da 10

  12. addipsy

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    where to buy cialis
    cheap generic cialis
    non generic cialis
    <a >buy cialis generic</a>

  13. frarkiny

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    professional business plan writing services uk
    write my essay
    help for assignment
    <a >essay writing website</a>

  14. Algova

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    generic cialis pro cialis
    cheap generic cialis
    generic cialis 20mg target mexico
    <a >cialis coupon</a>

  15. Ovence

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    university assignment help australia
    dissertation writing services
    write my eassy
    <a >writing services</a>

  16. Payoda

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    web md cialis pills order
    generic cialis online
    generic cialis from india
    <a >cialis coupon</a>

  17. glymmerb

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    business plan writers nottingham
    writing services
    getting help with a business plan
    <a >how to write an essay</a>

  18. vonsell

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    buy cialis online canada buy
    cheap generic cialis
    real cialis pills cialis
    cheap generic cialis

  19. iminity

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    academic writing services hgse
    dissertation writing services
    business plan writers virginia
    how to write an essay

  20. Rolafaky

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    cialis pills for women
    buy cialis generic
    cheap brand cialis
    cialis

  21. Algova

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    help writing short story
    writing services
    professional cover letter writing service uk
    write my paper for me

  22. durotte

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    women cialis generic
    cialis
    buy generic cialis online
    cheap generic cialis

  23. iminity

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    business plan writer pro
    dissertation writing services
    lab report writing service
    thesis writing service

  24. Engergo

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    definition of cialis tablets
    generic cialis online
    cialis 20mg tablets cialis
    <a >buy cialis generic</a>

  25. dierarp

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    assignment help site
    write my essay
    law assignment help uk
    <a >write my essay for me</a>

  26. Appeft

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    nortriptyline with food cialis 20mg
    buy cialis generic
    order cheap cialis online cialis
    <a >generic cialis</a>

  27. Darinue

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    business plan pro cheap
    thesis writing service
    business plan writers orange county
    <a >writing services</a>

  28. durotte

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    buy cialis europe
    cialis coupon
    manly cialis tablets
    <a >generic cialis</a>

  29. Rolafaky

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    help with annotated bibliography
    assignment help
    custom book report
    <a >write my essay</a>

  30. Pyptoma

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    online cialis no prescription
    generic cialis
    test cialis 20mg
    <a >cheap generic cialis</a>

  31. Boyhow

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    price of cialis tablets
    cialis coupon
    cuba gooding cialis generic
    <a >buy cialis generic</a>

  32. Engergo

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    who can help me find someone
    dissertation writing services
    need help with my assignment
    <a >write my essay</a>

  33. Payoda

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    assignment for sale
    write my essay for me
    reliable writing service
    <a >write my essay</a>

  34. aftelt

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    legitimate buy cialis online
    buy cialis generic
    generic cialis tadalafil cyclic guanosine monoph
    <a >generic cialis online</a>

  35. sleeli

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    do my accounting assignment
    essay writing website
    business plan writers in los angeles
    <a >thesis writing service</a>

  36. elunny

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    risks buy tadalafil
    cheap generic cialis
    viagra adalah cialis pills
    <a >cialis coupon</a>

  37. gahRassy

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    do my business assignment
    assignment help
    help with a literature review
    <a >write my essay</a>

  38. tigarne

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    cialis ordering
    buy cialis generic
    brand name cialis online
    <a >cheap generic cialis</a>

  39. RoolevoP

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    corporate finance assignment help
    write my paper
    apa annotated bibliography website
    <a >writing services</a>

  40. infibCib

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    generic cialis side effects
    cialis coupon
    buy generic cialis
    generic cialis

  41. Boyhow

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    ucas statement help
    thesis writing service
    college level papers for sale
    write my essay

  42. pilmitle

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    sample cialis generic
    cialis coupon
    what are the best cialis pills
    <a >buy cialis generic</a>

  43. aftelt

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    how can a business plan help you run your business
    write my paper for me
    college chemistry help websites
    <a >writing services</a>

  44. Rolafaky

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    cialis prescription online
    buy cialis generic
    cheap cialis
    <a >cheap generic cialis</a>

  45. elobamn

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    generic cialis vs brand cialis
    buy cialis generic
    cialis 5mg price drugs buy
    <a >cheap generic cialis</a>

  46. TubWoono

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    writing help review
    dissertation writing services
    product review writing service
    <a >thesis writing service</a>

  47. Broago

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    assignment writing service review
    write my essay for me
    help with making a business plan
    <a >dissertation writing services</a>

  48. Algova

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    business plan to buy a motel
    essay writing website
    financial accounting assignment help
    write my essay for me

  49. aidette

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    us pharmacy cialis generic medications
    cheap generic cialis
    manly cialis tablets
    generic cialis online

  50. Accery

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    us cialis online pharmacy buy viagra cialis a
    generic cialis online
    generic cialis safe
    <a >cialis coupon</a>

  51. dierarp

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    assignment helpers
    write my essay
    bibliography helper
    <a >write my paper for me</a>

  52. sutrargo

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    cialis cost
    generic cialis online
    indian cialis generic levitra
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  53. vonsell

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    algebra 2 help
    write my paper for me
    business plan writing services india
    <a >how to write an essay</a>

  54. Leargo

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    eli lilly weight loss pill cialis 20mg
    generic cialis online
    viagra v levitra cialis pills
    generic cialis online

  55. Rolafaky

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    writing business plan services
    assignment help
    help with writing business plan
    essay writing website

  56. Unlari

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    buy an assignment online
    write my essay
    business plan writer wanted
    <a >dissertation writing services</a>

  57. nadbak

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    montreal cialis generic buy
    buy cialis online
    buy generic cialis online no prescription
    <a >cheap generic cialis</a>

  58. durotte

    http://essaywritingservise2me.com
    need a ghostwriter
    write my paper for me
    paraphrase helper
    <a >write my essay for me</a>

  59. TubWoono

    http://cialisfgrx.com
    sample cialis generic
    cialis coupon
    what is generic cialis
    <a >generic cialis online</a>

  60. getgurge

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra cancer
    viagra online
    viagra cheap
    <a >buy viagra</a>

  61. blooth

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    buy cialis generic pharmac
    buy cialis online
    cialis online prescription
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  62. aidette

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    is viagra safe
    buy viagra
    viagra for the brain
    <a >cheap viagra</a>

  63. iminity

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    cialis and viagra together
    cheap viagra
    100mg viagra price
    <a >viagra online</a>

  64. blooth

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    order generic cialis india
    buy cialis online
    generic for cialis
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  65. glymmerb

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra faq
    viagra cheap
    viagra 8
    buy viagra

  66. Appeft

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    coreg antidote cialis pills buy
    buy cialis online
    generic cialis overnight delivery
    buy cialis online

  67. Accery

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra 2 chainz mp3
    buy viagra
    viagra porn
    generic viagra

  68. MokBlolf

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    cialis vs viagra reviews
    generic viagra online
    viagra alternative
    cheap viagra online

  69. Rolafaky

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    cialis order online buy
    buy cialis online
    real cialis pills
    cheap cialis

  70. glymmerb

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    generic cialis mexico
    buy cialis
    viagra rapid tabs cialis pills
    buy cialis online

  71. Ovence

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    generic viagra 100mg
    buy viagra
    viagra 3 day free trial
    <a >online viagra</a>

  72. famtrami

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    generic cialis ship to canada
    buy cialis online
    safe cialis pills
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  73. elunny

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    price of viagra
    buy generic viagra
    female verion of viagra
    <a >generic viagra online</a>

  74. Appeft

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    can u buy viagra over the counter cialis generic
    buy cialis online
    where to buy generic cialis
    <a >buy cialis</a>

  75. Payoda

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    herbal viagra for sale
    buy viagra
    viagra 500
    <a >cheap viagra</a>

  76. Unlari

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    difference between cialis and viagra
    buy viagra
    viagra for bph
    <a >buy viagra online</a>

  77. Unlari

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    buy real cialis online
    buy cialis
    walmart pharmacy viagra cialis generic cialis
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  78. blooth

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra 4 hours warning
    generic viagra online
    how much viagra cost in canada
    <a >cheap viagra online</a>

  79. MokBlolf

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    phentermine civr cialis 20mg
    buy cialis
    viagra for sale after an o
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  80. Jumnsern

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    how long before sex should i take viagra
    generic viagra online
    herb viagra side effects
    <a >generic viagra</a>

  81. durotte

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    is there a generic for cialis
    buy cialis online
    prednisone and hyperglycem
    <a >cialis online</a>

  82. aftelt

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra x donne
    generic viagra
    viagra video
    <a >buy generic viagra</a>

  83. blooth

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    low blood pressure canada buy generic cialis
    buy cialis
    is cialis available in generic
    <a >buy cialis</a>

  84. Fegarse

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra substitute over the counter
    generic viagra online
    how to make viagra
    viagra cheap

  85. undize

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    comprare price cialis generic
    cialis
    where to buy cialis
    <a >buy cialis</a>

  86. Meawliz

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra capsules
    generic viagra online
    walgreens viagra
    <a >cheap viagra</a>

  87. Leargo

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    fiat viagra commercial
    cheap viagra
    viagra without presc
    <a >cheap viagra online</a>

  88. Draife

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra over the counter cvs
    generic viagra online
    viagra us
    <a >buy viagra online</a>

  89. gahRassy

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    canada cialis generic sudden hearing loss
    buy cialis
    order cialis online without a rx
    buy cialis

  90. Ziviato

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    buy cialis online doctor
    buy cialis online
    mixing cialis generic viagra
    <a >buy cialis</a>

  91. Pyptoma

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    order cialis soft
    cialis
    online buy generic cialis
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  92. Testini

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    is cialis better than viagra
    buy generic viagra
    asian girl in viagra commercial
    buy viagra

  93. durotte

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    generic cialis tadalafil 20mg cialis
    buy cialis online
    cialis price
    <a >buy cialis online</a>

  94. tigarne

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    200 milligram viagra
    viagra online
    buying viagra
    <a >generic viagra</a>

  95. SexGycle

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    generic cialis online india
    cheap cialis
    buy cheap generic cialis
    cialis

  96. Ovence

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    viagra for men online
    generic viagra
    viagra pricing
    <a >buy generic viagra</a>

  97. Reignee

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    buy cheap viagra
    buy generic viagra
    viagra online without prescription
    generic viagra online

  98. iminity

    http://cialisbxonlinerx.com
    brand cialis buy online
    cheap cialis
    woman commercial buy generic cialis
    <a >cialis</a>

  99. Boyhow

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    using viagra
    viagra online
    viagra 4 hours warning
    <a >generic viagra online</a>

  100. TyncSymn

    http://buyrxviagraonlinerx.com
    how much does viagra cost with insurance
    cheap viagra online
    fucking on viagra
    <a >cheap viagra online</a>